BBC's star presenters 'underpaid' compared to US and European counterparts

The BBC published the salaries of its top-earning stars for the first time on Wednesday to address concerns that on-air talent at the UK’s public broadcaster was being overpaid. The truth: they’re taking home a lot less than their global counterparts.

Former Top Gear host and radio presenter Chris Evans led the payroll, earning about ?2.2 million in 2016, the British Broadcasting Corporation said in its annual report Wednesday. Match of the Day presenter Gary Lineker and chat-show host Graham Norton took home about ?1.75 million and ?850,000 respectively.

That’s well above the average salary of ?44,000 taken home by stage managers, producers, sound engineers and other employees of the world’s oldest national broadcaster. Yet given the salaries offered to TV talent across the globe, UK taxpayers might count themselves lucky.

Norton hauls in less than one-tenth the pay of US talk show host Jimmy Fallon, who earned $15 million in 2016 from NBC, according to Forbes. Even in the UK, ITV’s Ant and Dec, hosts of Britain’s Got Talent and “I’m a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!” earn ?5 million per year each, according to The Guardian.

“I completely understand that to lots and lots of people these are very large sums but we are a broadcaster, a global broadcaster, in a very competitive market,” BBC Director General Tony Hall said on the network’s Radio 4 Today programme. “We have to be competitive, but not foolishly.”

NBC news anchor Lester Holt earned an estimated $4 million per year as of 2015, dwarfing the annual salary of the BBC’s top newscaster Huw Edwards, who earns between ?550,000 and ?599,000.

Across Europe, the comparisons are similar. In France, Vivendi SA-owned Canal+ retains TV presenter and comedian Cyril Hanouna on a 50 million euros per year deal, well above the ?350,000 to ?400,000 earned by newsreader and Antiques Roadshow BBC star Fiona Bruce. Italy’s state broadcaster RAI reportedly pays host Fabio Fazio about 12 million euros per year, beating the ?200,000 to ?250,000 earned by Dan Walker, who presents the BBC’s morning news programme.

Germany’s Guenther Jauch, who moderates quiz shows including the German version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? for RTL Group S.A., will make about 5 million euros this year, according to Vermoegenmagazin.de. Jeremy Vine, presenter of the BBC’s Eggheads quiz show and a daily host on Radio 2 as well as a well-known election-night analyst, earned about ?700,000.

Spanish morning magazine presenter Ana Rosa Quintana, who works for Mediaset Espana’s free-to-air channel Telecinco, reportedly earns 4 million euros each year, about seven times more than the highest-paid woman on the BBC list, TV host Claudia Winkleman, who earns between ?450,000 and ?500,000 each year.

The salary data revealed a significant gap in pay between men and women. Winkleman, the former presenter of Strictly Come Dancing, is paid less than at least six men. Only one-third of those on the list of BBC employees who earn more than ?150,000 a year are women.

Speaking on BBC Radio 4 this morning, Director General Hall said the broadcaster needed to go “further and faster” on gender issues. Hall said he wanted to close the gender pay gap and have equality on screen and radio by 2020.

Kiran Daurka of legal firm Leigh Day said the gender debate was welcome but many groups were under-represented and more pay gap reporting was needed. “The glass ceiling is a barrier to women, people of colour and disabled people,” Daurka said.

The UK government ordered the BBC to release the figures to boost transparency at a time when the broadcaster is seeking to save 800 million pounds a year. (The BBC said it surpassed a target for ?700 million this year.) Like other traditional broadcasters and pay-TV companies such as Sky and ITV, it’s trying to stay relevant as digital rivals such as Netflix foment changes in viewing habits.

“Licence-fee payers have a right to know where their money goes,” Culture Minister Karen Bradley said last year. “By making the BBC more transparent it will help deliver savings that can then be invested in even more great programmes.”

Bloomberg